Reasoning methodology

Appeal to authority (improper)

Using endorsement as evidence when the authority is not enough.

Definition

A claim is supported primarily by who endorses it rather than by evidence, and the authority is outside their domain or no evidence is cited where evidence is expected.

Detection criteria

Requires authority-as-evidence plus domain mismatch or missing supporting evidence.

Genuine instances

  • A celebrity says the treatment works, so the article presents it as proven.

Common false positives

  • A specialist explains findings and cites the underlying study.