Court Finds AI Hallucinations in Filing by Former State Senate Candidate

Tricia S. Lindsay, attorney for plaintiff Sai Malena Jimenez-Fogarty, responded to two motions to dismiss by filing a pair of memoranda of law that cited to numerous nonexistent cases. In response, the Court ordered Lindsay to show cause why she should not be sanctioned for her misleading filings. Upon consideration of Lindsay's response to these orders, we find that she should be sanctioned in the amount of $2,500.00 …. [T]wo briefs were signed by Lindsay, and each contained a number of fabricated citations. When we say "fabricated," we do not mean citations that arguably contain typographical errors—for example, Lindsay's citations to cases that exist and support the propositions for which they were cited but are not located in the volume or at the page of the reporter (or database identifier) given. Similarly, we exclude any otherwise correct citations that give the wrong case name. We also exclude those instances where the cited case covers the same topic as the proposition for which it is cited but where the case's holding is completely mischaracterized, although such a citation is itself grossly misleading and perhaps deserving of sanctions. Instead, we consider only citations to cases that cannot be located at all by